Book Reviews, Young Adult

Review: A Summer Promise by Robin Jones Gunn

As 14-year old Christy leaves her family’s Wisconsin farm to spend the summer at her wealthy aunt and uncle’s beach home in Newport, she realizes this could be the best season of her life. Through it all, will Christy keep her promise to her parents not to do anything she’ll regret?

–back cover of A Summer Promise by Robin Jones Gunn

There are some parts of this book that are good and some parts that could be improved, but overall this was a pretty good read for the right audience. I think that this book is definitely for younger teens, and I also think that it may be more so a book for Christians than for those of different faiths. I think that some things said in the book may have been said in an offensive manner.

I think that Christy is a great representation of a fourteen-year-old girl. It shows the awkwardness and insecurities that often come with this age. Christy experiences self-image issues and an aunt who is so concerned about Christy’s appearance passes down some of that fear to her. This can happen so often in families, and I think that Gunn portrayed this wonderfully.

That being said, her aunt drove me crazy. I think that she was unnecessarily cruel throughout the whole book. I loved her uncle’s carefree approach to life though. Todd, the love interest, occasionally drove me crazy, because he didn’t seem that interested in Christy. He seemed more interested in leading her to God and controlling her. He could be inconsiderate and a bit of a jerk at times, but he could also be really sweet when he wasn’t being a jerk. Overall I found him immature and annoying.

The two characters that I liked the most were probably two of the secondary characters, Tracy and Allissa. Tracy wasn’t in this book much, but she seemed like she was a lot more well-rounded than the other characters, and a lot less judgemental. Allissa seemed to be one of the more interesting characters because of her lifestyle. It was like she was being shamed by the author for being sexually active, though, and I did not appreciate that.

As for the writing style, I felt as if she had done a great job. I have no complaints here, really. She did well.

The plot was interesting, especially around the climax. The author held my attention throughout the whole book, but I think that the plot was used as a tool to preach to people. I understand that in Christian fiction there will be Christianity, but I think that this went too far. It wasn’t intricately woven into the plot; it was literally a character standing in front of others speaking to them in a preachy manner. There were also strong undertones of, “if you don’t believe, you will be thrown into hell.”

For the right audience, this book would be enjoyable, but I still found some issues with it despite that. So, I give it 3 out of 5 stars.